« Today in History - June 26 |
Main
| Non-Discrimination in 17 USC 115 Reform »
June 26, 2005
More Pre-Grokster Commentary
Posted by Ernest Miller
The pre-Grokster commentary continues. Boy will I be glad when we finally get a decision.
Hilary Rosen weighs in from the Huffington Post, arguing that the marketplace is where the issue will really be settled: The Supreme Wisdom of Not Relying on the Court:
This is a big case with lots of money poured into it from all sides. It is said that the Supreme Courts decision will be one of the most important copyright cases ever on the books. I think it has all the makings of being famous for another reason. Because while the victory of whoever wins maybe important psychologically, it just wont really matter in the marketplace.
The article is also interesting in that Rosen now self-identifies as a consumer. As if. And, yes, the marketplace will create a solution, but the law creates the marketplace. Does Rosen think the marketplace would be the same no matter the decision?
Chris Nolan looks at the meta-commentary in eWeek (Preparing for the Grokster Watershed). No matter what the decision, the lawyers and lobbyists win as the case will move from the judiciary to the legislature.
The fight to change copyright law isn't going to be cheap, short or sweet for anyone.
Scrivener's Error continues to get a jump on the competition (Another Advanced Note on Grokster).
Another change in rhetoric that I'd prefer to see is eliminating the purported distinction between contributory and vicarious copyright infringement; instead, I prefer the term "indirect", which is less inflammatory, more accurate. and a better description of the general class of behavior without getting bogged down into questions of "fault." Copyright is, after all, a strict liability statute; importing fault into it should concern only the remedy (or perhaps highly limited defenses), not liability. However, that would require a wholesale rewriting of the law of indirect infringement by Congress, which Congress explicitly refused to do when adopting the DMCA. [emphasis in original]
UPADATE 0810PT
For post-
Grokster commentary see here:
Grokster Loses - Unanimously - Inducement Test?.
Comments (0)
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Copyright | File Sharing
- RELATED ENTRIES
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 23
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 22
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 21
- Kitchen Academy - The Hollywood Cookbook and Guest Chef Michael Montilla - March 18th
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 20
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 19
- Kitchen Academy - Course II - Day 18
- Salsa Verde