Home > Brain Waves
About this author
Zack Lynch Zack Lynch is the executive director of the Neurotechnology Industry Organization (NIO) and co-founder of NeuroInsights. He serves on the advisory boards of the McGovern Institute for Brain Research at MIT,Center for Cognitive Liberty & Ethics, the Center for Neuroeconomic Studies and SocialText, a social software company. He is currently writing a book on how neurotech is shaping business, politics and culture. Please send newsworthy items or feedback - to Zack Lynch.
Receive by email

GUEST AUTHOR ARCHIVES
NEUROTECH REPORT
120_NIR_2008_Cover_120.jpg 2008 Industry Report Available
NEUROTECH NEWS
NEUROTECH INDEX
INDUSTRY REPORT 2008
INVESTMENT NEWSLETTERS
BLOGS I READ
Cognitive Daily
CogNews
Neurodudes
Steven Johnson
Marginal Revolution
Mind Hacks
Neuro-journalism Mill
Neurolearning
Ross Mayfield
Future Pundit
Pat Kane
Pipeline
Virginia Postrel
Brad Delong - Econ
Business Pundit
Tech Central
Technorati Profile
NEURORESOURCE LINKS
Affective Computing
Journal of Bioethics
BioSpace
Bus. 2.0 Neurotech
Cerebrum
Drug Discovery World
Emotions Research
European Brain Council
Faster Cures
Neuroscience Info
Gyre-Neurotech
NIO
Neurotech market
Int'l Brain Research
Neuro-Jobs
McGovern MIT Brain Research
Neuroeconomics
Neuroethics
Neuroesthetics
NeuroInsights
Neurosociety Analysis
Nobel
PharmaPortal
Play Ethic
Rutgers Memory Lab
NEWS SOURCES
Bio-IT World
BioTech Today
BusinessWeek
Corante Biotech
Discover
Economist
Forbes
Fortune
Genetic Engineering News
GenomeWeb
Human Nature
J. Neurobio Learning
J. Neuroscience
J. Complexity Psych.
Nature-Neuroscience
Nature-NeuroPharma
Nature- NeuroNews
NY Times - Science
The Scientist
Reason Magazine
Science Magazine
Seed Magazine
ORGANIZATIONS
BLTC
Bionomics
CDC
Cold Spring Harbor
Center for Cognitive Liberty
Dana
Gruter Institute
Keck-UCSF
NBIC
US Bioethics
NIO
NeuroInsights
NCBI
NCGR
NIH
NIMH
Neuroscience Society
Scripps Research
Pubmed
Weizmann Institute
Whitehead Institute
Mind Brain






Subscribe with Bloglines
Check out the The AppGap - a group blog on the tools and trends that are changing the way we work.


Brain Waves
September 04, 2003
Enabling Enhancement?Email This EntryPrint This Entry
Posted by Zack

I'd like to return to an interesting point brought up by Pat Kane in To the Victor, the Paradoxes:



"What is the difference between performance-enhancing and performance-enabling drugs - the steroids that propel a runner slightly faster, the corticosteroids that stop a pro-footballers joints seizing up?"


Depending on your dictionary, the following definitions might help a bit:




  • Enhancement: To make greater, as in value, beauty, or effectiveness; augment.


  • Enablement: The act of enabling, or the state of being enabled; ability...To clarify more...


  • Enable: To supply with the means, knowledge, or opportunity; make able

How will popular conceptions of the phrases "performance enhancement" and "performance enablement" influence the way people perceive future uses of neurotechnology?


In the minds of many, performance enhancement carries feelings of artificiality, lacking of achievement, being a perversion of medicine, and even being an unnatural shortcut, while performance enablement projects images of empowerment, lifting the bottom up, and even fairness. (For an extremely informative discussion read: Enhancing Human Traits: Ethical and Social Implications.)


For example, will a college student who uses a cogniceutical to improve memory retention be viewed as unfairly enhancing her performance or will her use of a cogniceutical, which enables her to do the same work in a shorter period of time, be seen as an intelligent use of humanity's latest set of tools? 


Is there really a difference or is this just a question for marketing?


Category: Neuroethics


COMMENTS
Bang Boat on August 2, 2004 04:33 AM writes...

great site

Permalink to Comment
Bang Boat on August 2, 2004 04:42 AM writes...

great site

Permalink to Comment


TRACKBACKS
TrackBack URL:




POST A COMMENT
Name:

Email:

URL:

Comments:

Remember personal info?



EMAIL THIS ENTRY TO A FRIEND
Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):




RELATED ENTRIES